Introducing A L Nalick
By Barry Homrighaus RM1548, Stephen Alpert HLM10, Arturo Del Favero HLM552
The three coins shown below were frst suggested as a match sixteen years ago by then OHNS Archivist Arturo “Cinco” Del Favero. Art recalled a BoTales article by Stephen “Big One” Alpert, penned nine years earlier, which described a coin with the words “BY AL NALICK” punched on the reverse (#1). Art owned two coins he believed were matches, one with the inscription “BY ALN” (#2), and one with no name or initials (#3). BoTales editor Ralph “Bazoo” Winter reprinted Steve’s article along with pictures of all three coins in 2009 and issued a call for anyone who had information about Nalick, or had a matching coin. There is no record of a response to that call.
I discovered these articles when reviewing old copies of BoTales and endeavored to track down A. L. Nalick. My research came to a dead end. I found a wealth of information on a gentleman named A. L. Nalick who lived at the right time and had the right engraving and jewelry skills to have been the carver of these coins. But the Nalick I researched had no children; and distant relatives with whom I corresponded could provide no insights.
The OHNS team who review potential matches agree that these coins are the work of a single artist. So, while we cannot
identify Mr. Nalick as a known carver, we can recognize him with the nickname, “A L Nalick.”



The carving characteristics for "A L Nalick" are listed as follows:
- Smooth felds with LIBERTY remaining but dates removed.
- Straight-brimmed derby hats with low (#1 & #2) or medium height crowns.
- No profle changes.
- Chiseled or wriggle-cut full beards that come to a point at or near the rim.
- Added eyebrows over slightly modifed eyes.
- Engraved ears with some internal detail. Top of ear on carvings #2 & 3 partly under brim.
- Hair and beard do not connect below ear, leaving a clean neck.
- Plain, straight, high collars above defned lapels.
- All carvings have additional carved or liner tool texture or detail on collars and lapels.
- Matching style of punched lettering on reverse of two coins (#1 & 2). No name or initials on #3.
